***Disclaimer***

Disclaimer: The Wizard of 'OZ' makes no money from 'OZ' - The 'Other' Side of the Rainbow. 'OZ' is 100 % paid ad-free

Sunday, May 25, 2025

The 411 - If trains use diesel engines to power electric motors, why don't trucks do the same?

Canadian Pacific Engine

411Trains often use a setup known as a diesel-electric system, where a diesel engine generates electricity to power electric motors that drive the train's wheels. This configuration is chosen for several reasons, including efficiency, flexibility, and the ability to distribute power to multiple axles along the length of the train.

Trucks, on the other hand, typically use a different powertrain system. Most trucks on the road are powered by internal combustion engines, usually fueled by diesel or gasoline. These engines are directly connected to the wheels via a transmission system. This setup is known as a mechanical drivetrain.

While the diesel-electric system works well for trains, it may not be as suitable for trucks due to different operational requirements and constraints:

  1. Size and Weight: The components of a diesel-electric system, such as generators and electric motors, can be heavy and may not be as compact as a traditional truck engine and transmission. Trucks often have space and weight constraints that make a direct mechanical drivetrain more practical.

  2. Efficiency: Direct mechanical drivetrains can be more straightforward and efficient for the types of start-stop driving and varied speeds that trucks encounter on roads. They are optimized for the range of operating conditions typically encountered in trucking.

  3. Cost: The additional components required for a diesel-electric system can add complexity and cost. Trucking companies often prioritize cost-effectiveness and reliability in their choice of vehicle configurations.

  4. Infrastructure: The existing infrastructure for trucks, including fueling stations and maintenance facilities, is built around conventional internal combustion engines. Transitioning to a new system would require significant changes to infrastructure.

While there is ongoing interest in alternative power sources for trucks, such as electric and hybrid technologies, these typically involve modifications to the traditional mechanical drivetrain rather than adopting a diesel-electric system similar to trains. Advances in battery technology and electric drivetrains for trucks are being explored as ways to improve fuel efficiency and reduce emissions in the trucking industry.

Source: Some or all of the content was generated using an AI language model

No comments: