The scene I'm referring to from the Pirates of the Caribbean movies, where Jack Sparrow escapes from Davy Jones's Locker by turning his boat upside down and submerging, is more fantasy than reality. In real life, going underwater in an upside-down boat would not be a viable means of escape. Here's why:
Buoyancy: A boat is designed to be buoyant, meaning it floats on the water's surface. When a boat is flipped upside down, it loses its buoyancy and instead fills with water, making it extremely difficult to submerge. Even if you could somehow manage to flip a boat upside down underwater, it would not remain submerged for long without external forces keeping it down.
Air Trapped: In the movie scene, Jack Sparrow and his crew manage to trap air beneath the overturned boat, allowing them to breathe while submerged. In reality, it would be nearly impossible to create an air pocket large enough to sustain human life under an upside-down boat. The force of water pressure would quickly collapse any trapped air pockets.
Water Pressure: The deeper you go underwater, the greater the water pressure becomes. As the boat descends, the pressure on its structure would increase dramatically, potentially causing it to collapse or implode under the pressure.
Oxygen Deprivation: Even if somehow air pockets could be maintained under the boat, there would still be the risk of oxygen depletion over time. Breathing in a confined space with limited airflow would quickly lead to a buildup of carbon dioxide and a decrease in oxygen levels, posing a serious risk to anyone inside.
In conclusion, while the scene makes for entertaining fiction, going underwater in an upside-down boat like Jack Sparrow would not work in reality. It's important to remember that movies often take liberties with physics and reality for the sake of storytelling and entertainment.

1.The right quantity of air in flipped boat could keep it semi-floating, the up-force of the air equals the down force from the boar weght. so technical possible. 2. If you can breathe for 1min with the head in a relative small sealed bag, it's not a problem to breathe many minutes in the air under a relative large boat. 3. True only for very deep levels. A few meters doesn't matter that much. 4 is 2 using other words. Answer is the same - possible
ReplyDelete